Ranking Aristocrats by yield, highest first, is useful only with a safety column next to it. The top yielders on the list are usually the ones the market trusts least: mature, slow-growing, sometimes ex-growth.
The smarter ranking: yield divided by payout ratio risk. A 4% yielder at 50% payout outranks a 5.5% yielder at 85% payout, because the second one is a cut waiting for a recession.
Also check yield on cost, not current yield. A stock bought at 2.5% with 8% annual dividend growth pays 5.4% on your cost in ten years and nearly 12% in twenty. That compounding is the actual engine of dividend growth investing.
Read the Aristocrats list as a menu of proven raisers, then sort by safety, not by yield. The highest yield on the list is usually the least safe income on it. DivPlan ranks raisers by safety-adjusted yield for $9.99 one-time. Sources: Nasdaq, Morningstar